| Photo | Name | # | Pos. | Grad. | B | T | Ht. | Wt. | School | Hometown | State | Conference |
| Bryan Barnes | | INF | 2011 | L | R | 5'10" | 170 | Ohio University | Terrace | WA | Mid American |
| Jordan Becker | | Asst. Coach | | | | | | Marietta College | Johnstown | PA | Ohio Athletic Conference |
| Andy Carter | 4 | P | 2011 | R | R | 5'11" | 180 | Shawnee State University | Ashtabula | OH | Mideast |
| Matt Croglio | | P | 2012 | R | R | 6'4" | 185 | College of the Holy Cross | Fayetteville | NY | Patriot League |
| Tim Culver | 15 | Asst. Coach | | | | | | Fresno Pacific University | Lancaster | CA | |
| Tory Doerr | | P | 2012 | L | L | 6'3" | 190 | Wabash Valley College/Bradley University | Bethalto | IL | GRAC/Missouri Valley |
| Addison Dunn | | P | 2013 | R | R | 6'0" | 190 | Kent State University | Warren | PA | Mid American |
| Mike Florak | 35 | Head Coach | | | | | | Youngstown State University (fmr Head Coach 9 yrs) | Steubenville | OH | |
| Cameron Flynn | | OF | 2011 | L | R | 6'0" | 185 | Morehead State University | Lexington | KY | Ohio Valley |
| Troy Forton | | INF | 2012 | R | R | 6'2" | 200 | Western Michigan University | Muskegon | MI | Mid American |
|
| Danny Gifford | | P | 2012 | L | R | 6'2" | 210 | Wabash Valley College/Bradley University | Mt. Carmel | IL | GRAC/Missouri Valley |
| Ryan Jones | | IF | 2012 | R | R | 5'10" | 170 | Michigan State University | East Lansing | MI | Big Ten |
|
| Kevin Kiermaier | | OF | 2011 | L | R | 6'1" | 200 | Parkland/Purdue | Champaign | IL | Big Ten |
|
| Sam Mahoney | | C | 2011 | L | R | 6'5" | 220 | Ohio University | Columbia | SC | Mid American |
| John Martinez | | C/OF | 2013 | R | R | 5'10" | 185 | Michigan State University | Auburn Hills | MI | Big Ten |
| Robbie Moir | | OF | 2012 | L | R | 6'0" | 200 | Boston College | Symour | CT | Atlantic Coast |
| Chris Moore | 32 | Pitching Coach | | | | | | Shawnee State University (Asst. Coach) | Tacoma | WA | American Mideast |
| Trent Moses | 22 | INF | 2011 | R | R | 6'4" | 215 | Southeast Missouri State University | Advance | MO | Ohio Valley |
|
| Wes O'Neill | | INF | 2011 | R | R | 5'9" | 180 | Ohio University | Mississauga | ONT | Mid American |
| Spenser Payne | | OF | 2011 | R | R | 6'0" | 200 | Boston College | Kirkland | WA | Atlantic Coast |
| John Pedrotty | | P/OF/1B | 2012 | L | L | 6'3" | 205 | College of the Holy Cross | Portsmouth | RI | Patriot League |
|
| Luis Pollorena | | P | 2013 | | | 5'8" | 160 | Marion Military Institute | Laredo | TX | ACCC |
| Trey Popp | | P | 2011 | L | L | 6'0" | 185 | Michigan State | Portage | MI | Big Ten |
| Matthew Robertson | 30 | P | 2012 | L | R | 6'4" | 220 | Morehead State University | Harrodsburg | KY | Ohio Valley |
|
| Jandy Sena | | P | 2012 | L | R | 6'7" | 280 | Marion Military Insitutute | Miami | FL | ACCC |
| David Starn | 18 | P | 2012 | L | L | 6"3" | 190 | Kent State University | Hudson | OH | Mid-American |
|
| Seth Streich | | P/INF | 2012 | L | R | 6'3" | 200 | Ohio University | Ridgway | PA | Mid American |
| Andrew Wazsak | | P | 2013 | R | R | 6'2" | 195 | Michigan State University | Rochester Hills | MI | Big Ten |
| David Wierenga | | P | 2013 | R | R | 6'5" | 210 | Grand Rpids CC | Grand Rapids | MI | MCCAA |
|
| Darin Worman | | P | 2011 | R | L | 6'4" | 175 | Parkland/Eastern Illinois | Dieterich | IL | Big Ten |
| David Wright | | P | 2011 | R | R | 6'5" | 225 | Kent State University | Salem | OH | Mid American |